Sunday 20 Apr
 
 
 photo 85cca911-3826-446b-828b-785107dd2ef3_zpse09f07ac.jpg

 

OKG Newsletter


Home · Articles · Opinion · Letters to the Editor · How Manilow can...
Letters to the Editor
 

How Manilow can you go?


Lana Hughes June 15th, 2011

Regarding Online Editor Stephen Carradini’s review (“A comprehensive overview of the ‘Copacabana’ hitmaker’s latest,” June 8, okgazette.com) of the album “15 Minutes” by Barry Manilow:

Stephen, really? This is what you call “comprehensive”? You can’t skip songs and call it a “track-by-track exploration.” (Strike one.)

You can’t quote lyrics and call it a “track-by-track exploration.” (Strike two.) You can’t reference/compare Neil Diamond and Billy Joel to Barry Manilow, and expect anyone to take you seriously. To be clear: That’s like comparing oil and water. They are completely different, they don’t mix, and should not be compared/ referenced because they are nothing alike.

Besides which it makes your references smack of desperation. (Strike three). It’s apparent your intent was to dislike this album no matter what, and it is also clear that you failed to complete your “track-by-track exploration” of this album because you didn’t really “listen” to it. Therefore, it negates any credibility you think you hold with your “comprehensive overview.”

If you can’t be bothered to listen, why would anyone take what you say with anything but a pinch of salt? If you had done your job and been objective (and actually listened), you would have noted the subliminal messages that are peppered in this album and transferred purely with musical inflection (genius!). And you would have caught those links, connections and unsung messages that string this album together so seamlessly, track by track.

This is the lamest “track-by-track exploration” of an album I’ve ever read. I’m surprised your editor even allowed this to go to print as it’s utterly useless. I’d advise you don’t give up your day job. If this were your day job and I were your editor, I’d fire your ass if you presented this to me as a “comprehensive overview,” because that’s a straight-up lie.

—Lana Hughes
Liverpool, England

 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
 

 

 
06.15.2011 at 11:21 Reply

Dang Lana, you just served up some humble pie from all the way across the pond!

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close