Tuesday 22 Jul
 photo BO-Button1_zps13524083.jpg


OKG Newsletter

Home · Articles · News · News · Bully pulpit

Bully pulpit

Oklahoma gets a starring role in a controversial documentary.

Phil Bacharach April 11th, 2012

Ty Field-Smalley had had enough of being bullied at his school in Perkins. Slammed into lockers. Shoved into a garbage can. Chocolate milk dumped on his head in the cafeteria.

Ty Field-Smalley

 On the morning of May 13, 2010, he and a friend were hanging out on gym bleachers before school when they were approached by a boy who’d been harassing Ty.

A fight ensued. Eleven-year-old Ty went home, suspended.

Later that morning, his parents said, the sixth-grader pointed a .22-caliber gun to his head and killed himself.

Kirk Smalley, Ty’s father, doesn’t look like a crusader. Tall and gangly, he’s a country boy through and through. The walls of the Smalley home are adorned with the mounted heads of deer and antelope. Since his son’s death, however, Smalley has made it his life’s work to educate people about bullying, a commitment that has taken him to nearly 400 schools nationwide.

“We’re not in it to change our school. We’re not in it to change America’s schools,” he said. “We’re in it to change the world.”

His story is among a handful prominently featured in Bully, a powerful documentary that opens Friday at AMC Quail Springs Mall 24. While the movie has only recently hit theaters, it has generated months of controversy, thanks to a prolonged ratings battle pitting its distributor, The Weinstein Company, against the Motion Picture Association of America.

At the center of the film are the tales of a few Oklahoma youths who were terrorized by bullying.

Not that viewers need to read much into that. Bully director Lee Hirsch, himself a victim of childhood bullying, said the problem transcends geographic or socioeconomic boundaries. According to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, roughly half of all children are bullied at some point during their school years, with about 10 percent harassed on a regular basis.

“I knew there were millions and millions of people who had a connection to bullying,” Hirsch said, “and there hadn’t been any [film] out there that was for them, that was real and raw and truthful — and also empowering.”

Capturing Bully on film

Kelby Johnson
In examining the social epidemic, Hirsch shot footage in schools from Massachusetts to Mississippi. Among the five stories that wound up making the final cut is that of Kelby Johnson. As a teenager growing up in Tuttle, she had come to terms early on with her being gay. Many of her high school classmates were less receptive. Students, and even teachers, taunted her.

“I remember one teacher who was calling roll,” recalled Johnson, “and she was like, ‘Boys,’ and then said ‘Girls,’ and then she stopped and said ‘Kelby.’ There were a lot of snide remarks from teachers. None of them had my back. They joined in with the kids, a really unsupportive school system.”

At one point, a group of boys in a minivan even ran into her as she stood on the side of a street. Johnson’s head cracked the windshield, but miraculously she avoided serious injury.

In 2010, Hirsch’s cameras were in Tuttle following Johnson when the filmmaker learned of Ty Field- Smalley’s suicide in Perkins.

In retrospect, Kirk Smalley said, it appeared that the quieter Ty was at home, the worse he was being bullied at school.

“We knew he was being picked on,” he said.

The boy’s mother worked for the school district. Her complaints about Ty’s treatment brought her crossways with her supervisor, according to Kirk Smalley.

“At that point, [Ty] quit telling us about it,” he said. “He was trying to protect his mama."

Alex Libby

Philip and Jackie Libby knew all too well the implications of a tight-lipped child. They were living in Sioux City, Iowa, when they learned that Hirsch was shooting footage at the middle school of their son, Alex. Hirsch had noticed the boy, then 12, sitting alone at school and eventually asked the Libbys if he could document Alex’s life at school and home.

“I wasn’t too hot on the idea,” Jackie Libby recalled. “In the end, we did it for Alex. We needed to know why he was so sad all the time. He wouldn’t tell us. We thought the best way to find out is to have someone follow him, a third party who could maybe tell us what was going on.”

They were shocked by what they discovered. Hirsch’s camera chronicled the boy being subjected to almost daily verbal and physical abuse.

Lee Hirsch
The Libbys eventually decided they could no longer remain in Sioux City. The couple and their five kids moved to Oklahoma, where they had developed a bond with the families of Ty Field-Smalley and Kelby Johnson.

Since their move, they said, Alex, who is now 15, has thrived at his Edmond high school.

“He got his grades back up to As and Bs, which we hadn’t seen since elementary school, and he doesn’t have problems at school,” Jackie Libby said. “We love it here. The schools are great and the people are very genuine.”

Rating reality

Until last week, The Weinstein Company was set to release Bully without a rating after the MPAA indicated that one too many F-bombs would necessitate an R rating.

Hirsch and others protested that the restriction would keep the movie from being seen by young people, who arguably have the most to gain from it. They were backed by an online petition signed by nearly 500,000 people. As weeks went by, however, it appeared the MPAA wouldn’t budge.

That changed on April 5, when the MPAA announced Bully will be rated PG-13. Hirsch made slight edits for the rating, but left intact a crucial and jarring scene aboard a school bus.

Hirsch said he thinks Bully arrives at a sort of “tipping-point moment” in which more and more young people are making a conscious decision to reject bullying.

“I think they’re wanting to understand how to make a change,” he said. “They’re starting to gain tools, and folks like us and many others are out there working hard to give them support and encouragement to step up in the face of it and stand up to it.”

Kirk Smalley isn’t waiting for the movie to change hearts and minds. He continues to travel the country, talking to schoolchildren and parents. But he said he believes Bully can be a galvanizing force in the fight.

“All kids need to see it. It’s a really powerful thing,” he said.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


04.12.2012 at 04:27 Reply

The biggest travesty when it comes to bullying is that the moment the victim lashes out at his agressors, he's instantly treated as the antagonist.  Let's face facts, if Ty had taken that gun and killed his bullies, he would have spent the rest of his life in prison.  Instead, he takes his own life, and his bullies get to go about their business.  That's a horrible injustice.  

I happen to have a very relatable story.  I'd been horribly bullied because of my weight in high school.  At one point, I was even spat on.  I tried approahing the issue through the proper channels (school administration), but they never actually addressed the problem.  Then, I kicked it up a notch by appearing on the "Leeza" show.  When the school district got a dose of public embarassment, my school life got a lot better.  Unfortunately, it's hard to grab national media attention these days, and let's be honest, it should never have to come to that.  School administrators have an obligation to keep the environment safe for all students, if they fail in this regard, then they simply do not deserve their positions.

For the record, when I was being taunted, I also had access to a .22 caliber pistol.  There were days when I fantasized about killing my bullies, and days when I'd hold the gun to my temple.  I don't know why exactly I never killed myself, but I know I didn't kill them because I wasn't the bad guy, and I refused to go down in history as a bad guy.


04.16.2012 at 09:19 Reply

The MPAA's R rating made no sense.  Each entry in the Austin Powers trilogy got a PG-13, despite incredibly raunchy material, including a character I will only call "Obese Illegitimate Child", since most comment boards won't allow me to post his real name.


How is it that Bully gets an R?


04.16.2012 at 02:45

There is a great documentary called "This Film is not yet Rated" that covers the strange arbitrary practice of MPAA ratings.

What I find interesting is what you find just by going back and watching movies that came out before the PG-13 rating.  Logan's Run had full frontal female nudity, and had a PG rating.  Heck there is a scene in that movie where Logan runs through what could only be described as an Orgy.