Thursday 24 Jul
 photo BO-Button1_zps13524083.jpg


OKG Newsletter

Home · Articles · News · News · To the letter

To the letter

The OKC school district begins investigating charges of grade-tampering by a high school principal.

Jerry Bohnen June 18th, 2012

The Oklahoma City school district has quietly begun investigating allegations of falsification of attendance records and grades leveled by former teachers, employees and students against the principal of Frederick A. Douglass Mid-High School. The disclosure came following the June 4 district board meeting in which a former teacher and an official of the Oklahoma City NAACP made second appearances bringing the allegations to the board’s attention.

brian+staples-douglass+high+small+28mhBrian Staples - Credit: Mark Hancock

“We have retained an investigator,” said Tammy T. Carter, general counsel for the school district. School officials said a private attorney is conducting the probe, but declined to release further details.

Some parents have complained that their children are being advanced through the school system without being educated. They have accused Principal Brian Staples of being responsible, adding that they are standing up for teachers who were fired for fighting what they claim is a scandalous system at Douglass.

A group of black teachers, aides and others contends they and “dozens of others” have been fired by Staples, who is white, since 2008 because they refused to change failing grades and poor attendance records to make the school look good. Many have signed affidavits pursued by Jacque Pearsall, an attorney who originally filed suit in December of 2010 on behalf of several Douglass workers who claimed they were fired for refusing to sign off on improved grades and attendance records.

One of those is Marcia Muhammad, a former Douglass assistant principal fired in 2010. Pearsall later withdrew the suit without prejudice and has until late this year to re-file it.

Muhammad’s son and two others are facing criminal charges of attacking and injuring Staples after the school board unanimously voted to fire the woman upon Staples’ recommendation. In the March 2010 assault, Staples was hit with a baseball bat by two men allegedly hired by Elijah Muhammad, 31.

Pearsall has employed the assistance of the local chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and its vice chairman, Roosevelt Milton, who addressed the school board June 4.

“The NAACP is very serious about these complaints,” Milton told board members. “We also want you to know we’re determined.”

Armed with affidavits
Staples’ accusers contend he has lied about grades and attendance records to burnish his reputation and keep the school off a state list of at-risk schools.

“We believe we have a principal falsifying records,” said Pearsall. “He’s passing students through the system to make the school look better and to win state championships.”

Pearsall has a number of signed affidavits from former Douglass students, teachers and employees.
Muhammad, the former assistant principal, contends Staples set up a program to hide failing students.

“During the 2008-09 school terms, Principal Dr. Brian Staples taught and instructed all the administrators to drop students if they missed one day of school. I knew that this policy was implemented at Douglass High School to make attendance records better than it really was,” she stated in her affidavit.

She cited an alleged case of one 10th-grade student who had all C’s in spite of a poor attendance record. Muhammad said she spoke to the student’s science teacher, who had brought records to show the student was supposed to have a D in that class. And Muhammad said she learned of other teachers who submitted failing grades only to have them changed to C’s by Staples.

Denise Baccus-Bowie, a veteran schoolteacher who said she was asked to resign at the end of the 2010-11 school year, charges that Staples was behind a system of changing F’s to C’s.  She maintains that less than one-third of Douglass’ freshman class was tested in Algebra I in 2009-10, and the rest of the class had been put into math enhancement at the direction of Staples.

In her affidavit, former music teacher Annita Lewis provided copies of failing grades she had submitted for more than a dozen students in the fall of 2010. On most, she had written: “F, no participation. No Grades. Excessive Tardies & Absences.” Lewis also said some failing students were removed from classes on test days and put into her choir where they were “hidden.”

Jacque Pearsall, left, with one of her clients, Stephanie Carter
credit: Jerry Bohnen

Among the angry parents is Donita Wesley. “I am writing to inform you that my son’s grade had been changed from the original grade,” she wrote. “Even though it was of benefit to us, the next school year we noticed that was changed. He was given an F for a choir class and it was changed to a C.”

Student accusations
Some former students have raised allegations, too. TeonTez Fortune, a player on the Douglass football team, claimed in his affidavit that he failed a geometry class and was never placed on the ineligibility list.

“I was given a C average passing grade for the semester and allowed to pass for the semester I had failed,” said the young man, who graduated in 2010.

Two other Douglass graduates maintain Staples was responsible for grade changing.

School district spokeswoman Tierney Tinnin issued a statement indicating that officials “do not want to jeopardize the integrity of the investigation.”

She went on to quote district Superintendent Karl Springer: “The Oklahoma City public school district is working with a third-party investigator to gather information regarding the allegations. District leaders will take the necessary actions pending the outcome of the investigation.”

Tinnin said Staples would not be available for comment.

Pearsall said she is intent on finding more former teachers and employees who lost their jobs and are willing to step forward with allegations against Staples.

Hey! Read This:

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


06.18.2012 at 07:50 Reply

Grade changing and attendance tampering happened this year at US Grant Hight School. Principal Tammy Sanders personally insured that students who never received instruction in certain classes were given credit for that class so they could pass. 



06.21.2012 at 07:08 Reply

As a former resident of Oklahoma City, and currently living in Philadelphia, I am saddened to hear about these allegations surrounding Dr. Staples.  Too many of our black children are being pushed through the system for the sole reason of making someone or some organization look good.  The end result is that we end up with students who are now on the streets and the future leaders of our communities with limited education and often turning to a life of crime because they do not have the proper skills to survive in our society.  The thing that disheartens me the most of that because this is taking place in Oklahoma City, the chances of anything happening to Dr. Staples (meaning dismissal or being charged with anything) is highly unlikely.  It is still my contention that Oklahoma City is a very prejudiced part of our country and because of that, it is very difficult to make any significant changes there.  I moved away from there several years ago because I realized that with being a black person in Oklahoma City it was almost certain that I would not be able to rise to the position I have acquired now in Philadelphia, PA where everything is so diverse.  The "slave" mentality is still alive and well in OKC!!!!


06.22.2012 at 11:20

Sounds like you paint all white people with the same brush.  While I'd agree that a lot of the political movements around here tend to be moronic, fear-based, and religious in nature, it's a broad statement to accuse the city as having a "slave mentality."  

What this guy did is very wrong, but it's also wrong to not levy fault on students who don't show up and don't bother to do the work.  It's not as though they were denied an opportunity to aquire the grades legitimately.  If that happened, and IF it was race specific I might play the racism card.  

Being a criminal has nothing to do with having a high school education handed to you.  If anything, just having the diploma opens more doors, and no one ever questions how well you did in high school because it's so general in nature.  All they care about is that you didn't give up before it was over.  I'd argue what makes a criminal is desire and apathy.  Everyone wants stuff, some are just too lazy to work for it.  That's not a race issue, it's a problem with everyone.  Why do you think we have cars?  Because we're too lazy to walk.  Why do we use e-mail?  Because handwritten letters require more physical effort and take too long to write and deliver.  We say these things make our lives better, but in a way, the things we own, and the things we want to own end up owning us.  When I think about "slavery" in a modern society, I think about people (such as myself) who bought into the dream of a home and two cars, and became a slave to a bank to get it.  

Wealth is perceived as freedom, and that's why so many envy the wealthy.  But the only truly free are the poor who want for nothing.  So the question is, how do we avoid becoming slaves to consumerism?  In this dichotomy, both the criminal and working are aspiring toward the same fatal goal; the aquisition of things.

What most should ask themselves is, has a possession ever "loved" you?  That answer can guide anyone conscious to a better life.  But we can't think about such existensial things; the new iPad is out, and we MUST have it.


10.10.2012 at 05:28 Reply

This is a witch hunt....The OKC Public School Administration has not supported Dr. Staples. Isn't it funny that this is happening just as the individual who attacked him and those that orchestrated the attack going to court this month?

And Zita, sounds like you have already found Dr Staples guilty...Too bad you did not stay in OKC and help "your" people as he has been doing for decades!