Behind a strip mall, The
Cow Calf- Hay is possibly one of the best hidden gems in Edmond. This
family-friendly restaurant is serving up juicy Certified Angus Beef
burgers, curly or sweet potato fries and signature sandwiches.
Opened in August 2011 by the same local owners of the popular sandwich shop City Bites, it’s evident from the decor that this eatery has the same quirky spirit of the Bites locations.
A life-size cow statue greets you upon entering. The worn, wood-grained restroom door is fashioned after an outhouse your great-grandma might have had on the farm.
For a juicy cheeseburger, the Classic Cow ($7.39) is the perfect choice. It’s topped with melted American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and pickles and served with your choice of fries or thick-cut onion rings. To add a little kick, the Western Burger ($6.79) includes grilled jalapeños, melted American cheese, smoked bacon, fried onion strings and is topped with a tangy barbecue sauce. All burgers are served in old-fashioned pie tins.
Cow Calf-Hay also features signature sandwiches like the ultimate chicken sandwich ($7.59) and pork tenderloin sandwich ($6.89). Both can be ordered to include fries, rings or a combo for an additional $1.50.
The kids’ menu choices of chicken tenders, cheeseburger or grilled cheese include curly fries and a soft drink, at a bargain for under $5.
If you’re really hungry, give the Six Shooter Challenge a try. This eating contest consists of consuming six half-pound cheeseburgers topped with two pieces of cheese each, a full order of onion rings and curly fries and a slice of Cow Pie Cake.
The dessert is made of a yellow marbled cake, smothered with a light, creamy topping and covered in bananas. It comes topped with strawberry sauce.
Among other rules, the entire meal must be consumed within 45 minutes or you will forfeit the $35 required to pay in advance.
The good news: If you don’t finish, you can take the leftovers home.
Oklahoma Gazette’s restaurant review policy is to highlight the positive aspects, and include constructive criticism regarding food, ambience or service when appropriate.