Carpenter Square ends season with Nicky Silver comedy The Agony & The Agony 

click to enlarge AgonyPR-471b.jpg

Rhonda Clark and the other minds behind Carpenter Square Theatre’s creative direction read all of playwright Nicky Silver’s new works. Finding one that’s a good fit for their intimate production setting is another matter.

Silver is a New York-based writer known for penning off-Broadway productions like 1993’s Pterodactyls, 1995’s Raised in Captivity and 2004’s Beautiful Child.

Clark, Carpenter Square artistic director, said they found a fitting production in Silver’s outrageous comedy The Agony & The Agony, which closes out the theater company’s 32nd season.

The show debuted June 24 and runs through July 16 at 806 W. Main St.

Traditionally, Carpenter Square presents an offbeat comedy each summer, ending its season on a high note.

The Agony, Clark said, is exactly that kind of production.

“This one definitely fits that [description] because the characters often turn out of the scene and address the audience directly,” she said.

Characters break the fourth wall to clue the audience in on how they feel or what they have been through.

Silver’s story follows a once-promising New York playwright on a long streak of tough breaks.

The Agony is partially based on the writer’s own experiences, and many of its characters reflect real-life struggles many starving artists face.

“They’re all kind of desperate in some way for work or money; they’re really a collection of losers,” she said. “They’re all down on their luck one way or another.”

Clark said while she often loves the premise of a story Silver sets up, his endings can leave her cold. Agony’s ending, however, feels truly satisfying.

Deep thought is not necessary to appreciate the show.

Instead, Clark advises theatergoers to sit back and enjoy the tale.

“It’s the same thing in the movies — they have their big blockbusters,” she said. “It’s more of a popcorn kind of story, and this definitely fits that.”

Nagging neurosis

The Agony’s title is a spoof of the 1965 Charlton Heston-led film (and preceding novel) The Agony and the Ecstasy.

Silver’s main character, Richard Aglow, portrayed by Jon Haque, is a struggling playwright married to a similarly situated actress, depicted by Christine Lanning.

However, Richard is gay, and their relationship is a marriage of convenience. Sharing a New York City apartment causes its own problems.

“On one level, they lead separate lives, but when it comes down to it, they support each other,” Clark said. “It’s an unusual relationship.”

Richard attends every support group he possibly can, at least until they figure out he doesn’t have the problems he claims.

Clark said the lead character is neurotic and has lived as a virtual hermit for several years as he struggled to write.

“We all have someone in our lives who makes every little thing major,” Clark explained.

Richard thinks his luck has finally changed after he completes the first act of a new play.

He calls his friends — including porn actor Chet (Dylan Cox) and his pregnant girlfriend Anita (Tiffany Tuggle Rogers) and New York producer Anton Knight (Mark Ingham) — over in an effort to get the show produced.

Fresh faces

The theater welcomes many new names with this show. Haque stars in his Carpenter Square debut.

Director Ronn Burton grabs the reins for the first time in the venue.

Clark said all of the show’s actors are new to Carpenter Square with the exception of Lanning and Rogers.

“We love having new energy and different actors for the shows because we do eight shows a year,” she said. “We love it when actors return, but then when we’ve got new faces, it’s great also.”

One of the characters in the play Richard is writing, the ghost of notorious real-life murderer Nathan Leopold, seemingly comes to life as a figment of the playwright’s imagination.

Leopold’s ghost is played by Alex Prather. Clark said the character’s energy is a stark contrast from the play’s other characters.

“What makes him funny is how dry and dead serious he’s playing the character,” she said. “Some of the other characters are just wild. They’re falling over sofas, they’re jumping on furniture in frustration, they’re leaping over things and then you’ve got this guy who is very serious, like a high-class wealthy smug from the ’20s.”
Clark also serves as the show’s costume designer, a role she often fills in Carpenter Theater shows.

Leopold’s mannerisms are not the only things that separate the character from the others.

Audience members will be able to spot the mobster right away.

“We’ve got ripped and torn jeans, we’ve got cutoffs, but then we have [Leopold],” she said. “It’s a very period look. We’ve got a pocket watch and a chain and the fedora.”

The Agony closes out Carpenter Square to the public for a month, but Clark said those in the theater get no break.

Instead, the company will be preparing and rehearsing for the start of its next season, which begins Sept. 2.

The artistic director said those accustomed to the city’s bigger venues will find Carpenter Square’s cozy theater is a refreshing change of pace.

The Agony, with its confined settings, is especially appropriate for the space.

“We’re a real intimate theater,” Clark said. “We have just 90 seats, so you’re going to feel like you’re almost in the New York City apartment in the Upper West Side with the actors.”

For more information, visit

Print Headline: Silver lining; Carpenter Square Theatre ends its season with Nicky Silver comedy The Agony & The Agony.

Pin It

Speaking of...

More by Ben Luschen

Latest in Arts

My Bloody Valentine @ Rodeo Cinema

View all of today's events »

© 2023 Oklahoma Gazette / Tierra Media Inc. All rights reserved.

Powered by Foundation