The method of direct democracy that brought medical marijuana, criminal justice reform and Medicaid expansion to Oklahoma will remain intact, for now.

In a 5-4 decision issued on Tuesday morning, the Oklahoma Supreme Court struck down Senate Bill 1027, a 2025 measure that made it harder to get an initiative petition on the ballot. The bill restricted signature collection by county, required circulators to be registered Oklahoma voters and granted more power to the Secretary of State’s office to craft an initiative’s gist, among other provisions.

Oklahoma’s initiative and referendum process was guaranteed by the state’s populist founders, who believed that citizens should have the right to act when their elected officials don’t. But ballot initiatives have been a thorn in the side of many Republican lawmakers, who argue that the process favors urban areas and has been corrupted by wealthy out-of-state special interests. Thus came SB 1027.

Four Oklahoma voters filed a lawsuit against the measure in June 2025, arguing that numerous restrictions violated their rights under state and federal law. The high court issued a temporary stay soon after.

Justices heard oral arguments in the case last November. At the hearing, the state maintained that the restrictions were narrowly tailored to ensure signature gatherers don’t focus their efforts only in urban areas. The plaintiffs argued that the law was so strict that it effectively killed ballot initiatives for all but the wealthiest groups.

In their majority decision, authored by Justice Noma Gurich, justices outlined several constitutional concerns, particularly with the provision per-county cap on collecting signatures.

“Never before have legal Oklahoma voters been outright prohibited from signing an initiative or referendum petition,” she wrote. “In short, this act severely disenfranchises voters in all 77 counties.”

The issue is likely to reemerge, either in the courtroom or when the Legislature reconvenes in February. In a statement, House Speaker Kyle Hilbert criticized the majority opinion and urged the state to appeal, describing the provisions of SB 1027 as reasonable.

“The fight to uphold the integrity of Oklahoma’s initiative petition process is not over,” Hilbert said.

In contrast, Senate Minority Leader Julia Kirt, D-Oklahoma City, praised the court’s ruling.

“This ruling puts power back where it belongs, with the people,” Kirt said in a statement. “Senate Democrats knew this legislation was unconstitutional and proudly fought for Oklahomans’ right to solve problems that out-of-touch politicians refuse to address.”

A related lawsuit, dealing with signature verification for State Question 836, remains pending. Supporters of the ballot initiative, which proposes establishing a top-two primary system, filed an objection to the state’s signature count that found more than 57,000 signatures were invalid. Justices considered oral arguments on the matter on Nov. 2.

Republished with permission from Oklahoma Watch.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *